Is Pumpkin Spice Love Over?

Is America’s obsession with pumpkin spice fading? Not entirely—it’s still a favorite, but its popularity isn’t what it once was.

With the first day of fall still more than a month away (September 22nd), a recent poll reveals that 58% of Americans no longer consider pumpkin spice the top fall flavor.

In fact, it ranked only fourth overall. Here are the Top 10 fall flavors that beat it out:

1. Cinnamon: 39% consider it a favorite fall flavor.
2. Salted Caramel: 37%.
3. Candy Apple: 36%.
4. Pumpkin Spice: Only 32% say it’s a favorite.
5. Maple: 28%.
6. S’mores: 28%. (Aren’t s’mores more of a summer treat?)
7. Pecan: 26%.
8. Toasted Marshmallow: 24%. (Is this really a fall flavor?)
9. Sweet Potato: 20%.
10. Cranberry: 19%.